The modeller's Hippocratic oath

Via this excellent Slate piece on the ethics of big data and machine learning (at the top of my mind after watching a DWP presentation on their forays into the field), there's this article by an ex-finance-worker-now-professor. Three lovely bits. First, their modeller's Hippocratic oath:

  • I will remember that I didn’t make the world, and it doesn’t satisfy my equations.
  • Though I will use models boldly to estimate value, I will not be overly impressed by mathematics.
  • I will never sacrifice reality for elegance without explaining why I have done so.
  • Nor will I give the people who use my model false comfort about its accuracy. Instead, I will make explicit its assumptions and oversights

This seems especially relevant at the moment as I'm finishing off something I know only tells a partial story, but I also know may be used by some people with an axe to grind. I'm not quite sure what's going to happen yet. Hopefully nothing.

Derman also says:

Unfortunately, no matter what academics, economists, or banks tell you, there is no truly reliable financial science beneath financial engineering. By using variables such as volatility and liquidity that are crude but quantitative proxies for complex human behaviors, financial models attempt to describe the ripples on a vast and ill-understood sea of ephemeral human passions. Such models are roughly reliable only as long as the sea stays calm. When it does not, when crowds panic, anything can happen.

This reminded me of Scott's forest parable: in this case, if the sea doesn't stay calm, perhaps there are ways of calming the sea rather than admitting the model might not be up to scratch. When does the model make the world?

Lastly, Derman quotes Edward Lucas:

If you believe that capitalism is a system in which money matters more than freedom, you are doomed when people who don’t believe in freedom attack using money.

Trump's Nevada win made this seem prescient. A man whose only real distinction is to be very, very wealthy (perhaps despite, rather than because of, his own efforts) ... well, we'll see. This year could end up pretty terrifying.
---
New year's earnestness 5/17. Nearing the end Feb?? Uh oh!

Comments

Are students get essay

Are students get essay writing pointers from dissertation writing carrier?
All form of training consists of lot of writing papers for their grade marks. It is not easiest obligations for most of the peoples due to the fact writing mission is a lot careworn subject matter.

They don't have any mind for the manner to make a very good writing essay for his or her checks and that they do now not have use their non-public thoughts. A number of them use their very personal mind to make their writing papers however they will do loads of spelling errors and grammatical mistakes for his or her writing papers so they're turning into on line writing resources and get actual company for his or her challenge count number.

Dissertation writing service is one of the true offerings for writing tasks because it's far keen to facilitate the students writing works. It is offer excellent and real writing techniques and the human beings learn lot of things and research drastically more from their mistakes than their achievement. A exceptional goal of this provider is the development of effective and technical writing abilities and speakeasy skills for university kids and its miles deliver lot functions for essay writing papers.

Get your paper well timed and professional help to your unique subject matter. They’ll answer your all question and doubts so don’t get fear to essay writing papers.